Bug 1219506

Hello Wang,
Could you look into this bug and update the status

Sorry for being late, I’m on my vacation.

Hi @Cliff, could you look at this, I think you are the right person for it.

I saw that you set the keyboard through "yast keyboard set layout". but the error happens on the console. they are all not controlled by iBUS. You'd better ask Yast team or systemd maintainer to find the reason.
Gnome's keyboard layout is controlled inside the gnome-control-center-> keyboard. If you setting in this field, but desktop applications displays input characters wrong, it is my bug.

Hello Swayammitra:
May I ask why you think this is ibus bug?
I saw you assign it to me without any comment, while I didn't see a obvious reason.
Regards!

Clif, Mitra is new to the SLE development. Perhaps you can help her find the proper assignee next time :) Myself I am not sure of the root cause of the problem and can only guess - I setting it back to the gnome team.

Michael, why is this bug set as a blocker? Is this blocking-bug? That is quite serious and means you cannot work because of this bug - your test suite is completely blocked. 
But I see x86 works as expected! Please correct if needed.

Hello Radoslav, I did not actively selected any flags, I got the default settings from the link you get in openQA to open bugs.

My main goal was to make the test failure visible, since it looks a product bug but I am not sure about the impact on 15 SP6, feel free to change it.
Maybe Santi can pitch in as well

(In reply to Radoslav Tzvetkov from comment #5)
> Clif, Mitra is new to the SLE development. Perhaps you can help her find the
> proper assignee next time :) Myself I am not sure of the root cause of the
> problem and can only guess - I setting it back to the gnome team.

Okay, I will do the preliminary analysis work.

(In reply to Michael Grifalconi from comment #0)
> Hello, please help me find the correct component if this is wrong.
> 
> The test is setting the keyboard layout to German, rebooting and checking
> that z and y are inverted.
> On Gnome login screen, it works as expected, but on the console it does not.
Hi Michael:
While the bug title is " openQA test fails in keyboard_layout_gdm ", but from your description, the gdm(Gnome login screen), is right, but the console is incorrect.
so the bug title is not fit for the test result. Am I right?

> 
> I changed the test for debug reasons:
> https://github.com/michaelgrifalconi/os-autoinst-distri-opensuse/blob/
> 39b476b283521fb327d9ef38d154882e45f4c1f1/tests/x11/keyboard_layout_gdm.pm#L39
> 
> Now we can see that right after the change, the console works as expected,
> "qwertz is written as qwerty":
> https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13412515#step/keyboard_layout_gdm/12
At this moment, based on the previous comment, the gnome login screen works as expected right?
Thank you!

> After reboot, gnome login screen works as expected:
> https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13412515#step/keyboard_layout_gdm/16
> 
> But console does not anymore:
> https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13412515#step/keyboard_layout_gdm/23

(In reply to Cliff Zhao from comment #10)

Hello Cliff,

the title is automatically generated since the openQA test module that fails, is called "keyboard_layout_gdm".

Test code can be found here: https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13641670/modules/keyboard_layout_gdm/steps/1/src

Latest test run can be seen here: https://openqa.suse.de/tests/latest?arch=aarch64&distri=sle&flavor=Online&machine=aarch64&test=extra_tests_gnome&version=15-SP6#
There is also a video available, issue is near the very end: https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13641670/video?filename=video.webm

And yes, the problem is the one stated in the first lines of my first comment: 
The test is setting the keyboard layout to German, rebooting and checking that z and y are inverted.
On Gnome login screen, it works as expected, but on the console it does not.

Please feel free to change the title with something you feel more correct or I can do that on your request.

Thanks!

Hi Michael:
Finnally, I downloaded the 15-SP6 iso, and manully re-test it.
I didn't run the script(changekbd.sh), I just login to the tty after I set keyboard to German, reboot and login. I saw the keyboard layout is german charactors as expection. I doubt if the script or testcase need update? My 15-SP6 ISO is SLE-15-SP6-Full-x86_64-PublicBeta-202403-Media1.iso.
This test is related with yast tool, but before we sent the issue to them, we should check the error is still there. Please help me take a look. Thank you so much!

Hello Cliff, thanks for looking into it.

In the first message there is a link for 'Always latest result in this scenario' and the latest from few hours ago is still failing: https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13782972#step/keyboard_layout_gdm/28

Can you confirm that when you tested, you:
- logged in, from console changed to German
- reboot, Gnome login is good (also in the test)
- switch to console and check if also good >> This is where the test fails

I will try to manually reproduce it on Monday and provide more info!

Hello, on x86 is not reproducible which makes sense since the test fails only on aarch64:

x86 latest run: https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13792590
aarch64 latest run: https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13810417#step/keyboard_layout_gdm/28

(In reply to Michael Grifalconi from comment #14)
> Hello, on x86 is not reproducible which makes sense since the test fails
> only on aarch64:
> 
> x86 latest run: https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13792590
> aarch64 latest run:
> https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13810417#step/keyboard_layout_gdm/28

I want to say that, I mean the current situation is you and I could not reproduce the case with the manual test, but the openQA test failed, which indicates that the test case has problems. it's better to contact the case maintainer to fix it first. When this test case runs correctly in the x86_64 platform, it is valuable to check other hardware platforms. Thank you!