Bug 1219162 - [Build 47.2] There have been unexpected orphans detected after migration
Summary: [Build 47.2] There have been unexpected orphans detected after migration
Status: IN_PROGRESS
Alias: None
Product: PUBLIC SUSE Linux Enterprise Server 15 SP6
Classification: openSUSE
Component: Media Content (show other bugs)
Version: unspecified
Hardware: Other Other
: P3 - Medium : Normal
Target Milestone: ---
Assignee: Eugenio Paolantonio
QA Contact: Radoslav Tzvetkov
URL: https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13320837...
Whiteboard:
Keywords:
Depends on:
Blocks:
 
Reported: 2024-01-25 04:18 UTC by Chenzi Cao
Modified: 2024-06-03 17:17 UTC (History)
4 users (show)

See Also:
Found By: openQA
Services Priority:
Business Priority:
Blocker: Yes
Marketing QA Status: ---
IT Deployment: ---

Attachments
orphaned packages on build 82.1 (50.00 KB, application/x-tar)
2024-04-23 06:47 UTC, Lemon Li 		Details
orphaned packages on GMC build 91.1 (1006 bytes, application/x-tar)
2024-05-20 06:55 UTC, Lemon Li 		Details
View All Add an attachment (proposed patch, testcase, etc.)

Note You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.
Description Chenzi Cao 2024-01-25 04:18:28 UTC 
There have been unexpected orphans detected after migration:

libamtk-5-0,libgnome-bluetooth13,libgssdp-1_2-0,libgupnp-1_2-1,libgupnp-igd-1_0-4,libmozjs-78-0,libnma0,libpoppler126,libtepl-6-0,pesign-systemd,python3-networkx,typelib-1_0-Gck-1,typelib-1_0-Gcr-3,typelib-1_0-GnomeBluetooth-1_0,typelib-1_0-NMA-1_0

Please find the openqa test results as below:

openQA test in scenario sle-15-SP6-Regression-on-Migration-from-SLE15-SPx-aarch64-online_sles15sp5_pscc_lp-basesys-srv-desk-dev-contm-lgm-tsm-wsm-pcm_all_full@aarch64 fails in
[orphaned_packages_check](https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13320837/modules/orphaned_packages_check/steps/15)

Steps:

- Boot an image of SLES15SP5 on aarch64
- Register the system and modules: basesystem module, server applications module,  desktop applications module, development tools modules, container module, legacy module, transactional update module, web scripting module, public cloud module, python3 module.
- Fully update the packages
- Online migration to SLES15SP6 build47.2 via proxySCC by yast2 migration
- After migration, check the orphaned packages

Observed the orphaned packages listet above.
Comment 1 Lemon Li 2024-01-29 04:05:12 UTC 
More orphan packages found on build 50.1,
https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13366161#step/orphaned_packages_check/15
https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13366168#step/orphaned_packages_check/15
https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13366164#step/orphaned_packages_check/15

The orphaned packages are: libamtk-5-0,libgnome-bluetooth13,libgssdp-1_2-0,libgupnp-1_2-1,libgupnp-igd-1_0-4,libmozjs-78-0,libnma0,libpoppler126,libtepl-6-0,pesign-systemd,python3-networkx,typelib-1_0-Gck-1,typelib-1_0-Gcr-3,typelib-1_0-GnomeBluetooth-1_0,typelib-1_0-NMA-1_0, libbind9-1600, libisccc1600, libns1604, nma-data
Comment 2 Eugenio Paolantonio 2024-02-23 16:23:45 UTC 
Heads up, on 58.1 this will still not be fixed has the package-lists themselves haven't not been updated.

But there might be some new packages, so please add those here if there is anything new.

Thanks in advance!
Comment 4 yutao wang 2024-03-01 02:22:08 UTC 
Original system sles15sp3 migration to sles15sp6 at x86_64, orphan list:
kernel-preempt-devel,libbind9-1600,libcbor0,libcpupower0,libecal-2_0-1,libedata-cal-2_0-1,libgnome-bluetooth13,libisccc1600,libixion-0_17-0,libns1604,liborcus-0_17-0,libphodav-2_0-0,libprotobuf-lite20,libpython2_7-1_0,python,python-base,python-gobject2,python-gtk,python2-cairo,python3-bind,typelib-1_0-Gck-1,typelib-1_0-Gcr-3,typelib-1_0-GnomeBluetooth-1_0
Refer: https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13648189#step/orphaned_packages_check/15
***************************************************************
Original system sles15sp4 migration to sles15sp6 at x86_64, orphan list:
abseil-cpp,argyllcms,bijiben,bijiben-lang,cheese,cheese-lang,colord,colord-lang,desktop-data-SLE-extra,dia,dia-lang,evolution,evolution-data-server,evolution-data-server-lang,evolution-ews,evolution-ews-lang,evolution-lang,evolution-plugin-spamassassin,farstream-data,fixmath-devel,flute,folks-data,folks-lang,freerdp,gegl-0_4,gegl-0_4-lang,gimp,gimp-help,gimp-lang,gnome-clocks,gnome-clocks-lang,gnome-color-manager,gnome-color-manager-lang,gnome-contacts,gnome-contacts-lang,gnome-disk-utility,gnome-disk-utility-lang,gnome-initial-setup,gnome-initial-setup-lang,gnome-music,gnome-music-lang,gnome-online-accounts,gnome-online-accounts-lang,gnome-photos,gnome-photos-lang,gnome-remote-desktop,gnome-remote-desktop-lang,gnome-shell-search-provider-contacts,gnome-shell-search-provider-gnome-clocks,gnome-shell-search-provider-gnome-photos,gnome-shell-search-provider-seahorse,gnome-video-effects,grilo-plugin-tracker,grilo-plugins,grilo-plugins-lang,gstreamer-plugins-farstream,gtkspell-lang,gutenprint,inkscape,inkscape-extensions-extra,inkscape-extensions-gimp,inkscape-lang,kernel-livepatch-5_14_21-150400_24_108-default,lensfun-data,liba52-0,libabw-0_1-1,libamtk-5-0,libavcodec58_134,libavformat58_76,libavif13,libavutil56_70,libbabl-0_1-0,libbase,libbox2d2,libcamel-1_2-63,libcbor0,libcdr-0_1-1,libcpupower0,libdmapsharing-4_0-3,libdvdread4,libe-book-0_1-1,libebackend-1_2-10,libebook-1_2-20,libebook-contacts-1_2-3,libecal-2_0-1,libedata-book-1_2-26,libedata-cal-2_0-1,libedataserver-1_2-26,libedataserverui-1_2-3,libEMF1,libeot0,libepubgen-0_1-1,libetonyek-0_1-1,libexttextcat,libexttextcat-2_0-0,libfarstream-0_2-5,libfolks-eds26,libfolks26,libfonts,libformula,libfreehand-0_1-1,libfreerdp2,libgadu3,libgdl-3-5,libgegl-0_4-0,libgfbgraph-0_2-0,libgimp-2_0-0,libgimpui-2_0-0,libgnome-bluetooth13,libgnome-desktop-3-19,libgom-1_0-0,libgssdp-1_2-0,libgtkspell0,libgupnp-1_2-1,libgupnp-igd-1_0-4,libical-glib3,libixion-0_18-0,liblangtag1,liblayout,liblensfun1,libloader,liblpsolve55-0,libmediaart-2_0-0,libmfx1,libmozjs-78-0,libmpeg2-0,libmspub-0_1-1,libmwaw-0_3-3,libmypaint-1_5-1,libmythes-1_2-0,libnma0,libnumbertext-1_0-0,libnumbertext-data,libodfgen-0_1-1,liborcus-0_18-0,libpagemaker-0_0-0,libphodav-2_0-0,libphonenumber8,libpoppler117,libportal0,libpotrace0,libprotobuf-lite20,libproxy1-networkmanager,libpskc0,libpurple,libpurple-branding-upstream,libpurple-client0,libpurple-lang,libpurple0,libqxp-0_0-0,librasqal3,librav1e0,libraw20,librdf0,libreoffice,libreoffice-base,libreoffice-branding-upstream,libreoffice-calc,libreoffice-draw,libreoffice-filters-optional,libreoffice-gnome,libreoffice-gtk3,libreoffice-icon-themes,libreoffice-impress,libreoffice-l10n-en,libreoffice-mailmerge,libreoffice-math,libreoffice-pyuno,libreoffice-share-linker,libreoffice-writer,librepository,librest-0_7-0,librevenge-0_0-0,librevenge-stream-0_0-0,libserializer,libstaroffice-0_0-0,libstoken1,libswresample3_9,libswscale5_9,libtepl-6-0,libvisio-0_1-1,libvncclient1,libvncserver1,libwinpr2,libwmf-0_2-7,libwpd-0_10-10,libwpg-0_3-3,libwps-0_4-4,libzmf-0_0-0,libZXing1,lifecycle-data-sle-module-python3,ModemManager-bash-completion,NetworkManager-openconnect,NetworkManager-openconnect-gnome,NetworkManager-openconnect-lang,NetworkManager-openvpn,NetworkManager-openvpn-gnome,NetworkManager-openvpn-lang,NetworkManager-pptp,NetworkManager-pptp-gnome,NetworkManager-pptp-lang,openconnect,openconnect-lang,patterns-desktop-books,patterns-desktop-imaging,patterns-desktop-mobile,patterns-desktop-multimedia,patterns-desktop-technical_writing,patterns-gnome-gnome,patterns-gnome-gnome_imaging,patterns-gnome-gnome_multimedia,patterns-gnome-gnome_x11,patterns-office-office,pentaho-libxml,pentaho-reporting-flow-engine,pesign-systemd,pidgin,pptp,python3-bind,python3-scour,remmina,remmina-lang,remmina-plugin-rdp,remmina-plugin-secret,remmina-plugin-vnc,rp-pppoe,sac,seahorse,seahorse-lang,simple-scan,simple-scan-lang,totem,totem-lang,totem-plugins,typelib-1_0-Gck-1,typelib-1_0-Gcr-3,typelib-1_0-GnomeBluetooth-1_0,typelib-1_0-MediaArt-2_0,typelib-1_0-NMA-1_0,xwayland
Refer: https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13648190#step/orphaned_packages_check/15
**********************************************************************
Original system sles15sp5 migration to sles15sp6 at x86_64, orphan list:
kernel-livepatch-5_14_21-150500_55_49-default,libamtk-5-0,libavif13,libcbor0,libcpupower0,libecal-2_0-1,libedata-cal-2_0-1,libedataserverui-1_2-3,libgnome-bluetooth13,libmfx1,libmozjs-78-0,libphodav-2_0-0,libpoppler126,libportal0,libprotobuf-lite20,librav1e0,libraw20,libtepl-6-0,pesign-systemd,python3-bind,typelib-1_0-Gck-1,typelib-1_0-Gcr-3,typelib-1_0-GnomeBluetooth-1_0
Refer: https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13648195#step/orphaned_packages_check/15
Comment 5 yutao wang 2024-03-01 02:25:59 UTC 
Original system sles15sp3 migration to sles15sp6 at aarch64, orphan list:
kernel-preempt-devel,libbind9-1600,libcbor0,libcpupower0,libgnome-bluetooth13,libgssdp-1_2-0,libisccc1600,libnma0,libns1604,libphodav-2_0-0,libprotobuf-lite20,nma-data,python3-bind,typelib-1_0-Gck-1,typelib-1_0-Gcr-3,typelib-1_0-GnomeBluetooth-1_0,typelib-1_0-NMA-1_0
Refer: https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13648198#step/orphaned_packages_check/15
************************************************************************
Original system sles15sp4 migration to sles15sp6 at aarch64, orphan list:
libamtk-5-0,libavif13,libcbor0,libcpupower0,libgnome-bluetooth13,libgnome-desktop-3-19,libgssdp-1_2-0,libgupnp-1_2-1,libgupnp-igd-1_0-4,libmozjs-78-0,libnma0,libphodav-2_0-0,libprotobuf-lite20,librav1e0,libtepl-6-0,pesign-systemd,python3-bind,typelib-1_0-Gck-1,typelib-1_0-Gcr-3,typelib-1_0-GnomeBluetooth-1_0,typelib-1_0-NMA-1_0
https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13648197#step/orphaned_packages_check/15
******************************************************************
Original system sles15sp5 migration to sles15sp6 at aarch64, orphan list:
libamtk-5-0,libavif13,libcbor0,libcpupower0,libgnome-bluetooth13,libgnome-desktop-3-19,libgssdp-1_2-0,libgupnp-1_2-1,libgupnp-igd-1_0-4,libmozjs-78-0,libnma0,libphodav-2_0-0,libpoppler126,libprotobuf-lite20,librav1e0,libtepl-6-0,pesign-systemd,python3-bind,typelib-1_0-Gck-1,typelib-1_0-Gcr-3,typelib-1_0-GnomeBluetooth-1_0,typelib-1_0-NMA-1_0
Refer: https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13648196#step/orphaned_packages_check/15
Comment 6 Sofia Syrianidou 2024-03-11 14:33:33 UTC 
Original system sles15sp5 migration to sles15sp6 on s390x, orphan list:
kernel-livepatch-5_14_21-150500_55_49-default,virt-v2v,virt-v2v-bash-completion
Refer: https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13713665#step/orphaned_packages_check/13
****************************************************************************
Original system sles15sp3 migration to sles15sp6 on s390x, orphan list:
libbind9-1600,libisccc1600,libns1604,nma-data
Refer: https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13713677#step/orphaned_packages_check/13
Comment 7 Lemon Li 2024-03-15 03:58:08 UTC 
More orphan packages found on build 64.2, migration from SLES 15SP5 to SLES 15SP6.
https://openqa.suse.de/tests/13785036#step/orphaned_packages_check/15

The orphaned packages are: kernel-livepatch-5_14_21-150500_55_52-default,libecal-2_0-1,libedata-cal-2_0-1,libedataserverui-1_2-3,libmfx1,libportal0,libraw20,xmlgraphics-batik,xmlgraphics-batik-css,xmlgraphics-commons,xmlgraphics-fop
Comment 8 Lemon Li 2024-04-02 05:59:34 UTC 
More orphan packages found on build 77.1, migration from SLES 15SP4 to SLES 15SP6.

https://openqa.nue.suse.com/tests/13915689#step/orphaned_packages_check/15

The orphaned packages are: abseil-cpp,argyllcms,bijiben,bijiben-lang,cheese,cheese-lang,colord,colord-lang,desktop-data-SLE-extra,dia,dia-lang,evolution,evolution-data-server,evolution-data-server-lang,evolution-ews,evolution-ews-lang,evolution-lang,evolution-plugin-spamassassin,farstream-data,fixmath-devel,flute,folks-data,folks-lang,freerdp,gegl-0_4,gegl-0_4-lang,gimp,gimp-help,gimp-lang,gnome-clocks,gnome-clocks-lang,gnome-color-manager,gnome-color-manager-lang,gnome-contacts,gnome-contacts-lang,gnome-disk-utility,gnome-disk-utility-lang,gnome-initial-setup,gnome-initial-setup-lang,gnome-music,gnome-music-lang,gnome-online-accounts,gnome-online-accounts-lang,gnome-photos,gnome-photos-lang,gnome-remote-desktop,gnome-remote-desktop-lang,gnome-shell-search-provider-contacts,gnome-shell-search-provider-gnome-clocks,gnome-shell-search-provider-gnome-photos,gnome-shell-search-provider-seahorse,gnome-video-effects,grilo-plugin-tracker,grilo-plugins,grilo-plugins-lang,gstreamer-plugins-farstream,gtkspell-lang,gutenprint,inkscape,inkscape-extensions-extra,inkscape-extensions-gimp,inkscape-lang,kernel-livepatch-5_14_21-150400_24_111-default,lensfun-data,liba52-0,libabw-0_1-1,libavcodec58_134,libavformat58_76,libavutil56_70,libbabl-0_1-0,libbase,libbox2d2,libcamel-1_2-63,libcdr-0_1-1,libdmapsharing-4_0-3,libdvdread4,libe-book-0_1-1,libebackend-1_2-10,libebook-1_2-20,libebook-contacts-1_2-3,libecal-2_0-1,libedata-book-1_2-26,libedata-cal-2_0-1,libedataserver-1_2-26,libedataserverui-1_2-3,libEMF1,libeot0,libepubgen-0_1-1,libetonyek-0_1-1,libexttextcat,libexttextcat-2_0-0,libfarstream-0_2-5,libfolks-eds26,libfolks26,libfonts,libformula,libfreehand-0_1-1,libfreerdp2,libgadu3,libgdl-3-5,libgegl-0_4-0,libgfbgraph-0_2-0,libgimp-2_0-0,libgimpui-2_0-0,libgnome-desktop-3-19,libgom-1_0-0,libgssdp-1_2-0,libgtkspell0,libgupnp-1_2-1,libgupnp-igd-1_0-4,libical-glib3,libixion-0_18-0,liblangtag1,liblayout,liblensfun1,libloader,liblpsolve55-0,libmediaart-2_0-0,libmfx1,libmpeg2-0,libmspub-0_1-1,libmwaw-0_3-3,libmypaint-1_5-1,libmythes-1_2-0,libnma0,libnumbertext-1_0-0,libnumbertext-data,libodfgen-0_1-1,liborcus-0_18-0,libpagemaker-0_0-0,libphonenumber8,libpoppler117,libportal0,libpotrace0,libpskc0,libpurple,libpurple-branding-upstream,libpurple-client0,libpurple-lang,libpurple0,libqxp-0_0-0,librasqal3,libraw20,librdf0,libreoffice,libreoffice-base,libreoffice-branding-upstream,libreoffice-calc,libreoffice-draw,libreoffice-filters-optional,libreoffice-gnome,libreoffice-gtk3,libreoffice-icon-themes,libreoffice-impress,libreoffice-l10n-en,libreoffice-mailmerge,libreoffice-math,libreoffice-pyuno,libreoffice-share-linker,libreoffice-writer,librepository,librest-0_7-0,librevenge-0_0-0,librevenge-stream-0_0-0,libserializer,libsrt1,libstaroffice-0_0-0,libstoken1,libswresample3_9,libswscale5_9,libvisio-0_1-1,libvncclient1,libvncserver1,libwinpr2,libwireplumber-0_4-0,libwmf-0_2-7,libwpd-0_10-10,libwpg-0_3-3,libwps-0_4-4,libzmf-0_0-0,libZXing1,lifecycle-data-sle-module-python3,ModemManager-bash-completion,NetworkManager-openconnect,NetworkManager-openconnect-gnome,NetworkManager-openconnect-lang,NetworkManager-openvpn,NetworkManager-openvpn-gnome,NetworkManager-openvpn-lang,NetworkManager-pptp,NetworkManager-pptp-gnome,NetworkManager-pptp-lang,openconnect,openconnect-lang,patterns-desktop-books,patterns-desktop-imaging,patterns-desktop-mobile,patterns-desktop-multimedia,patterns-desktop-technical_writing,patterns-gnome-gnome,patterns-gnome-gnome_imaging,patterns-gnome-gnome_multimedia,patterns-gnome-gnome_x11,patterns-office-office,pentaho-libxml,pentaho-reporting-flow-engine,pidgin,pptp,python3-scour,remmina,remmina-lang,remmina-plugin-rdp,remmina-plugin-secret,remmina-plugin-vnc,rp-pppoe,sac,seahorse,seahorse-lang,simple-scan,simple-scan-lang,timezone-java,totem,totem-lang,totem-plugins,typelib-1_0-MediaArt-2_0,xwayland

Migration from 15SP5 to 15SP6:
https://openqa.nue.suse.com/tests/13915693#step/orphaned_packages_check/15

The orphaned packages are: kernel-livepatch-5_14_21-150500_55_52-default,libdvdread4,libecal-2_0-1,libedata-cal-2_0-1,libedataserverui-1_2-3,libmfx1,libportal0,libraw20,libsrt1,libwireplumber-0_4-0,timezone-java,xmlgraphics-batik,xmlgraphics-batik-css,xmlgraphics-commons,xmlgraphics-fop

Migration from 15SP3 to 15SP6:
https://openqa.nue.suse.com/tests/13915698#step/orphaned_packages_check/15

The orphaned packages are: libbind9-1600,libisccc1600,libns1604,libsrt1,nma-data
Comment 9 Eugenio Paolantonio 2024-04-04 16:13:25 UTC 
Thanks for the up-to-date lists, I will include them all in an upcoming 000package-groups update :)
Comment 10 Lemon Li 2024-04-23 06:47:34 UTC 
Created attachment 874441 [details]
orphaned packages on build 82.1
Comment 12 Chenzi Cao 2024-05-16 07:00:58 UTC 
Hi, this the latest orphaned packages list from openqa results of build90.1:

https://openqa.suse.de/tests/14307396#step/orphaned_packages_check/15
aarch64: kernel-preempt-devel

https://openqa.suse.de/tests/14307408#step/orphaned_packages_check/15
s390x: virt-v2v,virt-v2v-bash-completion

https://openqa.suse.de/tests/14307409#step/orphaned_packages_check/15
s390x: kernel-livepatch-5_14_21-150500_55_62-default,virt-v2v,virt-v2v-bash-completion

https://openqa.suse.de/tests/14307411#step/orphaned_packages_check/15
x86_64: kernel-livepatch-5_14_21-150400_24_119-default

https://openqa.suse.de/tests/14307413#step/orphaned_packages_check/15
x86_64: kernel-livepatch-5_14_21-150500_55_59-default

https://openqa.suse.de/tests/14307416#step/orphaned_packages_check/15
ppc64le: virt-v2v,virt-v2v-bash-completion
Comment 14 Lemon Li 2024-05-20 06:55:43 UTC 
Created attachment 874966 [details]
orphaned packages on GMC build 91.1